Marketing and Conversion Optimization Blog

About the Invesp Blog

This blog is brought to you by the team at Invesp Consulting, an e-commerce conversion optimization company.

Meet the authors of the invesp blog: Ayat, Khalid , and Chris.

More about Invesp Consulting

Subscribe

RSS Subscribe via RSS Feed

Or, receive weekly updates by email:


Free Landing Page Templates

Landing page templates

Two easy to customize, highly converting landing page templates. Download Now!

By Ayat Shukairy on November 25, 2008 4:31 pm

I feel compelled to comment on a new trend perpetuated and identified by other marketing bloggers. Amazingly, there seems to be an anti-buyer persona movement. That’s probably a little dramatic. What’s really happening is that some marketing bloggers have begun to question the effectiveness of using elaborately detailed buyer personas to market and sell products. It just so happens that they’re doing it at the same time and it appears like an avalanche in the marketing blogger world.

Substantiated or not, I find even the thought of underestimating the power of buyer personas dangerous, as should anyone who has and will find success by correctly using them.

I don’t believe that anyone reading this blog would require a primer, but Adele Revella offers a very small one, if you’re interested. Even in a few paragraphs, she manages to convey how important buyer personas are to any marketer. She says that marketers "use buyer personas to clarify the goals, concerns, preferences and decision process that are most relevant to their customers."

Pretty important, huh? Given her definition, one could venture to say that any extremely focused and successful marketing campaign would find the neglecting of buyer personas impossible. Buyer personas are intricately wound into the fabric of marketing.

I’ve gathered that the naysayers don’t truly value all of the information collected and integrated into a buyer persona. They seem to think that some, if not most, details are unnecessary, make marketing jobs harder and can often result in disappointment because of hyper-segmentation.

And to that, I say this:

It’s true that creating and catering to buyer personas can result in wasted effort, marketing money and lowered sales…but only if one or the more major components of identifying and appealing to a buyer persona is off.

But I know how they would counter…

They would say that the danger of relying too heavily on buyer personas to sell a product is simple: predictable personas, regardless of the amount of research put into identifying into them, cannot account for the unpredictability of real, live people. My retort would be that they’re missing the entire point of using buyer personas. The goal is not to collect as much irrelevant information about a particular group of a buyers as possible and throw it into a buyer persona. It’s to collect information and identify relevancies within it. To do that, you have to examine all the information you have and delve a little deeper for more.

Buyers are puzzles and their personal details are the pieces that make the whole. To see the big picture, you simply have to find connections to the different parts and have them work together in a marketing campaign.

In addition, creating buyer personas helps potential customers understand you. It aids marketers create copy that speaks directly to them.  David Scott, author of The New Rules of Marketing and PR, puts it simply: taking buyer personas seriously helps differentiate your copy from the "ego-centric gobbledygook" that characterizes so much marketing material today. By using buyer personas, marketers understand that buyers have problems (often immediate) that need to be solved and they won’t necessarily be "sold" on a product if you simply list your business’s achievements and incomprehensible product specifications in an effort to get them to buy. The worst thing any marketer could do would be to leave prospects on their own with this type of information and hope for the best, but that’s exactly what some businesses do and they often suffer for it.

Regardless of what types of information a marketer may gather about his target market and what he discards and uses in his marketing efforts, one thing cannot be denied: buyer personas were created and are used to help give an extra marketing edge in highly competitive markets. It’s a popular and successful strategy because everything in a person’s past and present (including the supposed extraneous details) influences his future. This includes his future purchases.

I know that some readers may remain unconvinced with this post. As mentioned before, questioning the value of buyer personas may be in vogue. But to those people who remain adamant that buyer personas bear exaggerated importance, I would direct you to Kim Klaver’s challenge: create a buyer’s persona for yourself using one of your favorite products. Apply all the buyer’s persona principles to yourself and dare to realize just how valuable buyer personas are.

Note from Ayat: This is a guest post by Samantha Gonzales.

Share and Enjoy:
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • Propeller
  • Sphinn

RSS If you enjoyed this post, Subscribe to the Invesp blog to receive more posts!

12 Responses to “ Don’t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas”

 
EcommGuru Says -- November 25th, 2008 at 6:51 pm

My two cents worth on why personas are not useful in an ecommerce environment.

Take into consider our scenario. We sell products that are higher end products (price range of $400 up to $5000).

We have identified our site visitors into three groups: small business owners, network administrators and value added resellers. We have also identified ages, sex, and other traits for these personas.

HERE IS THE PROBLEM IN DETAIL:
It is near impossible to create product descriptions for each of these personas and present them in an organized fashion. Example: we can easily create three product descriptions for each item. However, you cannot control the product descriptions based on the user’s persona unless you invest a LOT of time and money it to creating a hyper-dynamic ecommerce application. It’s not worth the resources.

This is the problem companies face when dealing with personas. Even having two personas complicates the matters beyond any reasonable means to invest in pursuing.

 
Your Publicity To You » Blog Archive » Don’t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas | The … Says -- November 25th, 2008 at 8:11 pm

[...] unknown wrote an interesting post today onDonâ??t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas | The …Here’s a quick excerptI feel compelled to comment on a new trend perpetuated and identified by other marketing bloggers. Amazingly, there seems to be an anti-buyer persona movement. [...]

 
Linda Bustos Says -- November 26th, 2008 at 2:26 am

I think the value of customer personas are to get you thinking like a customer, and thinking like different customers. It’s not about covering all possible bases. I’d love to hear what the Future Now folks have to say :)

 
teaching reading strategies | Sun Microsystems Says -- November 26th, 2008 at 6:16 pm

[...] Don’t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas I don’t believe that anyone reading this blog would require a primer, but Adele Revella offers a very small one, if you’re interested. Even in a few paragraphs, she manages to convey how important buyer personas are to any marketer. … [...]

 
Adele Revella Says -- November 26th, 2008 at 7:37 pm

Thanks for the great post, Samantha (and Ayat). I want to speak directly to the comment from ecommGuru as it poses a great example of how current thinking interferes with the use of buyer personas. If you start with the products as the organizing principle in website design (or any marketing strategy), you will agree with ecommGuru — the typical site could not be scaled this way.

Here’s a radically different approach that is more helpful to your buyers. Consider that there are several different types of buyers visiting your site, each in search of answers to their problems. For those who know exactly which product will solve their problem, give them a list and they’ll be delighted. But for those less familiar with your products, offer an alternative set of content that is organized around buyer personas and their problems, and then lead them to the product that answers that problem. You’ll find that the site design is actually simpler — not more complex.

Here’s a website that made this change and grew revenue 160% in the first year after the change http://www.vantagemobility.com. No other marketing programs were adjusted — the result is entirely associated with the use of personas on that site.

Sorry for the long comment. This is my favorite topic.

 
ecommerce strategy | Dell.com Says -- November 26th, 2008 at 8:00 pm

[...] Don’t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas It’sa popular and successful strategy because everything in a person’s past and present (including the supposed extraneous details) influences his future. This includes his future purchases. I know that some readers may remain … [...]

 
Samantha Says -- November 27th, 2008 at 9:22 am

EcommGuru, thanks for your comment. I find buyer personas fascinating right now because of how they seem to polarize everyone from business owners to marketers to even buyers who resent being segmented. But I have come across folks who experienced similar situations to yours. What’s interesting is that they’re divided between thinking that buyer personas are not worth the investment and that they are their financial saving grace (after taking the plunge). Personally, I think it’s worth the investment, but can you tell me if you’ve tried working with your buyer personas or if you’ve just projected the expenses of time and money to be too costly?

Linda, those are absolutely benefits of using buyer personas, which is why it was amazing to me to read so much anti-buyer persona sentiment recently. How could any business owner or marketer turn his back on another way to get into his customers’ heads? It’s baffling. But very interesting.

Adele, long comments are very welcome! I’m so impressed with the example you included. I would love to see a comparison side-by-side shot with the old website.

 
Tony Zambito Says -- November 28th, 2008 at 10:02 am

Thank you or highlighting an issue that has been prevalent in the world of personas for some time. The real question is related to the “value” of buyer personas. Marketing bloggers are right to question the value of buyer personas however I submit that the creation and use of buyer personas are often misunderstood and misguided. My partner, Angela Quail, and I studied under Alan Cooper at the origins of personas in the late 90s. The term buyer persona was then used to describe who you were NOT creating a persona for. In the early part of this decade, Angela and I embarked on an endeavor to evolve the use of buyer personas for purchasing decisions and customer experience. I bring this up because as with design and user personas, buyer personas have no value if they have no contextual references. Much of the contextual references are brought to the srface through qualitative field study and the building of buying process scenarios (see my blog post:http://www.personainsights.com/persona_insights/2008/03/real-value-of-b.html). Also, one of the fundamental of persona creation has always been “goal” identification. Thus, what we see in some buyer persona creation circles is buyer personas created without the contextual and “goal” references which means their value is minimized. I applaud the efforts of the above mentioned for their advocacy of buyer personas - and your advocacy as well! If approached with same rigors needed for design personas, the value of buyer personas can be quite substantial.

 
teaching reading strategies | CNN.com Says -- November 28th, 2008 at 2:39 pm

[...] Don’t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas I don’t believe that anyone reading this blog would require a primer, but Adele Revella offers a very small one, if you’re interested. Even in a few paragraphs, she manages to convey how important buyer personas are to any marketer. … [...]

 
EcommGuru Says -- November 28th, 2008 at 6:54 pm

I appreciate everyones feedback on my commect. To round out my point futher I would ask if anyone has seen a reseller-based ecommerce site that sells B2B or B2C using personas? I have looked at all of the big ecommerce players (B2B and B2C) many of Invesp’s clients, FutureNow customers and in the Internet Retailer 500 and have yet to see any site using this technique.

@Adele
That is a great example of persona use. I concure there is a place for it in the marketing world.

 
what is the best money market account | Intel.com Says -- November 29th, 2008 at 2:04 am

[...] Don’t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas … achievements and incomprehensible product specifications in an effort to get them to buy. The worst thing any marketer could do would be to leave prospects on their own with this type of information and hope for the best, but that’s exactly what some businesses do and they often suffer for it. Regardless … [...]

 
Best Virtual Advertising » Blog Archive » Don’t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas | The … Says -- December 3rd, 2008 at 2:01 pm

[...] Ayat Shukairy wrote an interesting post today onDonâ??t Sell Yourself Short by Discounting Buyer Personas | The …Here’s a quick excerptIt’s true that creating and catering to buyer personas can result in wasted effort, marketing money and lowered sales…but only if one or the more major components of identifying and appealing to a buyer persona is off. … [...]

 

What do you think?